Deep Dives How Tos Newsletters Saved Articles Challenges

This November 2020, Movember tackles toxic masculinity

By Louis Shankar

Nov 11, 2020

COPY URL

We’ve reached November, and you know what that means: falling leaves, long nights, and moustaches! Movember is now an annual global event, raising both awareness and money for men’s health causes, in particular prostate cancer, testicular cancer, and suicide. “Men are dying on average 6 years earlier than women,” the charity explains on its website, “and for largely preventable reasons.”

Since starting in 2003, it now has over 5.5 million people across 20 countries growing ‘taches and donating to the charity. It raised a total of $911 million, which in turn has funded a total of 1,250 projects (as of 2017). Movember’s primary goal is to reduce the number of men dying prematurely by 25 per cent by 2030.

This November 2020, Movember tackles toxic masculinity

Due to the scope of its work, in terms of both economic and geographic scale, “Movember is uniquely placed to address this crisis on a global scale,” the charity explains. “We fund groundbreaking projects all over the world, engaging men where they are to understand what works best and accelerate change. We use funding to impact men’s health both locally and globally. We invest in country- and culture-specific health projects while collaborating on game-changing solutions that address the men’s health crisis on a global scale.”

While this explains the overriding geographic scope of Movember’s work, the charity also targets its support towards specific social groups such as gay, bisexual and transgender men who face specific health concerns, particularly mental health issues. “Multiple studies have found that non-heterosexual people face up to twice as much abuse or violence (including physical, mental, sexual or emotional) than their heterosexual counterparts,“ Movember highlights. “Prejudice and discrimination add a layer of risk on top of other factors which can lead to depression, anxiety and suicide.”

Australian project Stop. Think. Respect. has received $858,785 Australian dollars to “reduce the impact of anxiety and depression within LGBTI communities through reducing the discrimination they experience.”

Meanwhile, in Canada, the Movember Foundation funded M.bodiment, a project created by Egale Canada Human Rights Trust, is aimed at tackling “homophobia, biphobia, transphobia and all other forms of discrimination,” with the help of videos and an online hub that “undress the body image stigmas currently prevalent within the LGBT community to open a dialogue about gay, bi, trans, and queer men’s body image and its health implications.”

While some might assume that gay men are more ‘in tune’ with their prostates, that doesn’t necessarily mean that they are more comfortable than straight men when it comes to getting medical help. And while trans men are not at risk of prostate or testicular cancer, there are other physical and mental health issues particular to the community that warrant attention and funding.

In 2014, Movember became the first charity to start engaging with these important issues within the queer community by working with Prostate Cancer UK and the LGBT Foundation to launch the first-ever prostate cancer survivorship conference aimed at the Gay, Bisexual and Transgender community. “There are issues and concerns relating to prostate cancer that affect the GBT community that prove to be distinct,” Movember notes. “Anxieties surrounding sex, support, and experiences in the healthcare system are significant.”

The charity also set up support groups across England, which offered a space for survivors “to talk openly about how prostate cancer affects them and gain psychosocial support from someone going through a similar experience”, and in London, a peer mentorship scheme was established, “to train and match gay and bisexual buddies to men with prostate cancer.”

Not only men can grow moustaches, in much the same way that not all men can grow moustaches. I’m reminded of the razor company, Harry’s, who included queer men and non-binary people, such as Jonathan Van Ness in their recent Pride campaigns. Non-binary people can and do sport ‘taches—and there are non-binary people at risk of prostate and testicular cancers.

This year, Movember has introduced a non-binary option in sign-ups and its global diversity while it “further develops a more inclusive voice within the charity.”

It can be a difficult balance to strike, though, between inclusion and distraction. Movember is currently “the only global charity focused solely on men’s health” and having such a clear and distinct remit is important for its goals. An organisation as big as Movember is well placed to reach out to and support all manner of groups around the world, which is something it is certainly investigating: “While we are certainly working towards a complete diversity piece within the organisation, this is something we are working at on a global scale,” a Movember spokesperson explains. “Movember is inclusive of all people and our campaign is aimed at everyone who has an affinity with the cause areas.”

Change is coming this November. Are you ready for it?

This November 2020, Movember tackles toxic masculinity


By Louis Shankar

Nov 11, 2020

COPY URL


What the Gillette advert means for the fight against toxic masculinity

By Louis Shankar

Jan 22, 2019

COPY URL

Last week, Gillette launched a new ad campaign critiquing toxic masculinity—and the responses have been mixed, to say the least. So-called men’s rights activists have criticised the advert for being too preachy and critical of all men (#notallmen). The usual right-wing trolls—Tomi Lahren, Paul Joseph Watson, Piers Morgan—have called for boycotts of Gillette and for its parent company, Procter & Gamble, to apologise. The fact that such commentators love to label the millennial generation “snowflakes” for caring about identity politics and social injustice, while getting viscerally offended by a two-minute advert is, apparently, an irony lost on them.

One Twitter user decided to flush his razor down the toilet in protest. The replies to his outburst were not too kind: “My man here ruining his plumbing because a commercial suggested that maybe he should be nicer.” On YouTube, at time of writing, the video has 656,000 likes and over 1.1 million dislikes.

Screenshot-2019-01-22-at-08.54.58

The advert quotes Terry Crews, one of the leading examples of a more sensitive and considerate masculinity: “Men need to hold other men accountable.” As Rebecca Reid points out in her Telegraph column, “Men have just been told they’re not perfect by Gillette – that’s why they’re so angry.” The replies to the video on Gillette’s Twitter are, in equal parts, heartwarming and horrifying, many point out that the negative response is precisely why such a prominent advert is needed.

Because what does the advert actually say? How many people’s reactions were tempered by other reactions? Looking closely at the campaign itself, it’s hard to disagree with what they’re campaigning for. Although, perhaps, it’s a fault of the advert for not articulating the message clearly enough.

The advert marks thirty years of Gillette’s tagline, The Best A Man Can Get. This campaign, the company explains, is meant to interrogate that statement. “It’s time we acknowledge that brands, like ours, play a role in influencing culture. And as a company that encourages men to be their best, we have a responsibility to make sure we are promoting positive, attainable, inclusive and healthy versions of what it means to be a man.”

“From today on, we pledge to actively challenge the stereotypes and expectations of what it means to be a man everywhere you see Gillette. In the ads we run, the images we publish to social media, the words we choose, and so much more.”

This seems like a brand becoming genuinely aware of itself and the world around it; Gillette has a platform for communicating with a large audience and is committing to doing so in a thoughtful and responsible way, right? This seems to be reinforced by a pledge to donate $1 million per year for the next three years to charities with ”programs in the United States designed to inspire, educate and help men of all ages achieve their personal “best” and become role models for the next generation.”

It has partnered with Building A Better Man project, which seeks to reduce violent behaviour in young men, and The Boys and Girls Club of America, which helps young men develop better social and communication skills. The next ad in the series, no doubt in anticipation of the Super Bowl, partners with NFL rookie Shaquem Griffin: Your Best Never Comes Easy, reads the tagline. “From earning defensive player of the year in college, to suiting up for the Seattle Seahawks, hard work and a dedicated father have helped Shaquem overcome any obstacle”—what’s wrong with that?

Of course, there is also a cynical perspective one can take. P&G is a billion dollar company—its 2017 revenue was $65.05 billion—who could be seen to be cashing in on the current political moment of MeToo. The longterm buzz of this campaign is likely to outweigh any immediate backlash, as happened with Nike and its Colin Kaepernick partnership.

And, in an altogether misplaced critique, Piers Morgan pointed out that Chrissy Teigen, a spokesperson of Gillette’s line of razors for women, Venus, had posted transphobic and problematic tweets in the past: why weren’t they addressing this, he asked? Where’s the consistency? This is a valid question, but it doesn’t really detract from the core message of the new campaign, and for notorious transphobe Piers Morgan to be calling someone hypocritical for transphobia is taking both hypocrisy and obliviousness to new heights.

What is the best a man can get? Surely, calling for compassion doesn’t inherently sacrifice one’s masculinity? And to stand up against bullying and harassment—without using the old line “boys will be boys”—isn’t really too much to ask?

What the Gillette advert means for the fight against toxic masculinity


By Louis Shankar

Jan 22, 2019

COPY URL