Channel 4’s Go Back to Where You Came From is a disturbing social experiment that completely misses the mark

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Published Jan 17, 2025 at 01:58 PM

Reading time: 3 minutes

65199

Back in July 2024, Channel 4 announced a new reality show that almost made me pinch myself… Twice. The bizarre and tone-deaf series titled Go Back To Where You Came From, is a social experiment that promises to “challenge how British people feel about asylum seekers and immigration.” But let me be crystal clear: what Channel 4 is really doing here is broadcasting an exercise in colonial nostalgia wrapped in the guise of a thought-provoking documentary. This isn’t a bold commentary on immigration, it’s a dangerous, exploitative, and ultimately misguided display of privilege that misses the point by miles.

Now, months later—and with the show due to air on 4 February 2025—it’s time to take a proper look at this highly problematic show and exactly what it will consist of.

What is the show ‘Go Back To Where You Came From’ about?

Based on an Australian series that first aired in 2011, Channel 4’s version takes six British participants—each with opposing views on immigration—and drops them into some of the most dangerous and desperate regions on Earth. The participants will witness firsthand the harsh realities faced by refugees and migrants. Starting in Somalia’s Mogadishu and Syria’s Raqqa, two cities battered by years of war and suffering, these participants will supposedly “experience” the terror, poverty, and near-constant threat of violence that asylum seekers endure on their perilous journey to the UK. If you thought this was an attempt to humanise the refugee crisis, think again.

The show is set to air on 4 February 2025, and the decision to commission this series is a direct response to the ongoing immigration crisis in the UK. As Liam Humphreys, the show’s creator, said: “Immigration remains one of the most controversial and divisive topics in the UK,” citing the record number of people crossing the English Channel illegally in recent years. The show, he argues, will provide a “unique and compelling perspective” on the refugee experience. A perspective that, let’s be honest, is entirely centred on a group of privileged Brits stepping into the shoes of people they have so far only seen as statistics, not human beings.

Now, let’s be real: this reality show isn’t about empathy, it’s not even about education—it’s about exploiting misery for ratings. It’s the kind of spectacle that positions “the other” as something to be observed while reinforcing a hollow narrative of Western superiority. The tagline alone, “Go Back to Where You Came From,” feels like a punch to the gut—a slogan designed to provoke, manipulate, and stir up an already toxic atmosphere around immigration.

Who are the cast members on the new Channel 4 show?

Among the cast are Chloe Dobbs, a politics graduate from Oxford University and paddleboarding business owner, and Dave Marshall, a Nottingham-based chef turned TikTok personality who, according to the press release, was “gobsmacked by the poverty” he witnessed in Syria.

We’re supposed to believe that witnessing overcrowded refugee camps and dodging missiles will somehow spark an epiphany in people who have spent their lives at the top of the privilege ladder. The show isn’t about learning from others; it’s about reaffirming the belief that the UK—and its citizens—are somehow above it all.

Here’s the thing, we’re tired of this performative empathy. It’s the kind of thing that turns human suffering into an object of voyeuristic curiosity. Watching people travel to dangerous areas to learn about poverty and violence from a safe, TV-ready distance only reinforces the belief that these problems exist to be observed, not solved.

The truth is, the refugee crisis isn’t a reality show, it’s a human rights issue. And if Channel 4 were genuinely interested in educating its audience, it would have done so by featuring the stories of those affected, rather than pandering to the misguided notions of a few Brits who think a short trip to the world’s worst war zones will give them the keys to understanding asylum seekers. It’s time to stop pretending that this type of exploitative spectacle is educational.

The only thing this show proves is that the entertainment industry’s obsession with controversy and spectacle trumps any genuine attempt to spark meaningful social change. Channel 4’s Go Back To Where You Came From isn’t a breakthrough moment for understanding immigration, it’s a regressive step that undermines the very real struggles of those who have been displaced by war, poverty, and violence.

It’s time to hold the media accountable for the narratives they promote, and this “experiment” should be called out for what it really is: a disturbing attempt to profit from the pain of others.

Keep On Reading

By Monica Athnasious

Rumours of immigration control at predominantly Latinx Texas school shooting panics US citizens

By Louis Shankar

The UK announces a new points-based immigration system. Here’s what to expect

By Alma Fabiani

How voice profiling determines how to exploit your feelings, privacy and your wallet

By Charlie Sawyer

Who is shaman and conspiracy theorist Durek Verrett, Princess Märtha Louise of Norway’s new husband?

By Charlie Sawyer

4 important reasons why Blake Lively being controversial shouldn’t surprise anyone

By Charlie Sawyer

What does Brazil’s X ban mean for Elon Musk and his fellow tech bros?

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Who is Usha Vance? The divisive wife of Republican VP candidate JD Vance

By Charlie Sawyer

Cher Lloyd reveals she was told to seduce Justin Bieber when she was a teen

By Abby Amoakuh

Why are people tagging Bad Bunny in videos of them crying? The DtMF TikTok trend explained

By Charlie Sawyer

Republican Rep says he’d force his daughter to carry pregnancy from rape

By Abby Amoakuh

From rodent boyfriends to frog princes: Gen Z are not done with categorising men as animals

By Abby Amoakuh

UK search engines are now promoting tutorials on how to create deepfake porn

By Abby Amoakuh

Liam Payne’s death prompts backlash against girlfriend Kate Cassidy and ex-fiancée Maya Henry

By Abby Amoakuh

Trying to manifest your dream partner for 2025? Influencer-backed app To Be Magnetic says it can help

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Argentina’s President Javier Milei cloned his late dog, but where’s the fifth one he claims to have?

By Abby Amoakuh

Election Day 2024: What will a second Trump term mean for women across the US?

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

What Disney, Netflix, and Uber are hiding in their Terms of Service

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Woman who protested hijab law in Iran by stripping in public has disappeared after violent arrest

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Beyoncé dragged into Jay-Z and P Diddy assault allegations debate as controversy heats up online

By Louis Shankar

BlueSky sees 300% surge in users after 2024 US presidential election