The global clean beauty industry is growing faster than ever. But is it actually clean?

By Tahmina Begum

Published Nov 18, 2019 at 12:57 PM

Reading time: 4 minutes

4498

You must have seen the words ‘clean beauty’ while walking through a beauty aisle at your local Boots or checking out Amazon’s recommended face masks in an attempt to get rid of all your Saturday night regrets. But if you haven’t noticed, let me tell you, ‘clean beauty’ has definitely been on the rise. In fact, the global organic beauty market is set to be worth $54 billion by 2027.

That’s a lot of mullah for products that haven’t been around for that long. From decades of beauty trends that sell you ‘this’ new magic ingredient, it seems as though consumers are trying to be more conscious—and beauty and skincare brands see that. It’s actually what brands like Gwyneth Paltrow’s Goop and Kourtney Kardashian’s Poosh as well as thousands of other millennial skincare brands sell themselves on: blurring the lines between clean beauty and the wellness industry. So what is clean beauty? And what makes your bathroom cabinet dirty?

After Goop explained why clean beauty is important, the beauty buzzword kept appearing next to skincare and make-up that’s also marketed as being sustainable, organic and natural. When searching for clean beauty products, these descriptions become interchangeable, and though they appear to be mindful, all those terms have completely different interpretations.

Being a sustainable beauty company can mean anything from looking after its carbon, energy, water and waste and environmental impacts to having sustainable working conditions for its workers. But when it comes to clean beauty, no one seems to agree with the definition.

According to Goop’s definition, ‘clean beauty’ is not the same as ‘natural beauty’. Clean beauty products aim to be as toxic-free as possible, whereas natural ingredients can also be harmful. For example, a natural beauty product could contain only one natural ingredient, meaning that even if the product claims to be 100 per cent natural, it might not be 100 per cent great for your skin.

Research conducted by Holland & Barrett found that a fifth of women in the UK felt their beauty products would be less effective if they had fewer chemicals, and as many as 15 per cent admitted that looking good on the outside was more important than being healthy on the inside. Yet, somehow, the guilt of not buying clean products is very much there for a lot of women, along with the fear of ruining their Glossier-esque skin with chemical beauty products from the high street. This is exactly what drives the clean beauty industry forward.

Screen Shot spoke to Clare and Darren Cooper, founders of vegan and cruelty-free brand Made By Coopers, who believe clean beauty can also be natural, only if we stop using fillers, such as Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (what is commonly found across cheaply made beauty products) or mineral oils and non-vegan ingredients in them.

After a three-month yoga expedition in India where the duo used oils that benefited their minds as well as their skin, the Coopers started their first small-batch of modern apothecary, using what they learned from nature and the culture of taking care of your emotional wellbeing. When talking about what they think of the new beauty trend of being ‘clean’, they explained how this new wave of beauty came from the vague definition of ‘natural beauty’, “A brand can say ‘natural’ if it contains just a tiny percentage of natural ingredients and the rest could be made up of synthetic, harmful ingredients or even cheap filling ingredients with zero benefits such as water.”

On the other hand, head of beauty at Holland & Barrett, Joanne Cooke defines ‘clean beauty’ as all aspects of the product, “from non-toxic ingredients to packaging to a sustainable and ethical approach.” The leading health and wellness retailer’s own approach to clean beauty is more filtered. According to Holland & Barrett’s standards, a list of 155 ingredients are considered ‘unclean’—anything that may compromise a consumer’s skin, hair, face or body.

Yet just like ‘natural’, ‘sustainable’, ‘green’ and ‘eco’, ‘clean beauty’ is not a universal definition, as ‘clean’ products are not tested nor measured by EU regulations in any way. And still, there is a clearly defined movement towards using only squeaky-clean, transparent beauty products.

From Glossier and MILK to Beauty Pie, even the packaging for beauty products has changed. Looking au naturel is in. But Brooke DeVard, host and creator of Naked Beauty, the podcast bearing all things beauty, and a natural beauty hack who doesn’t put anything on her skin and in her belly that she can’t pronounce, believes this can be a cop-out for brands green-washing their products. “They know people barely read labels so they just need to create the impression of ‘clean beauty’, even using images of plants or lots of neutral colours in the packaging to signal it’s ‘eco-friendly’.” 

Yet the optimist in DeVard believes this move towards clean beauty is a good thing, “The less harmful, synthetic ingredients we have on our skin, the better. Corporations are driven by profit so they’ll only create what they believe consumers want, but their investment in this space shows how much our purchasing patterns have changed.” Cooke also explained how large this trend is as “natural beauty has become the fastest-growing category in Holland & Barrett’s 800 UK and Irish stores.” This recent growth shows that more and more consumers are looking for beauty products that have a clean and conscious approach, understanding that these will be absorbed by the skin.

Still, the choice of seeking out clean beauty can feel like a luxury to some. Not only do products that tend to be ‘clean’ come with a hefty price tag (with Goops’ Luminous Melting Cleanser starting at £80), but going through an ingredient list itself is time-consuming. Maybe it is time we start demanding more transparency from beauty brands. As beauty podcast host DeVard said, “it’s the tools of self-education that will make the most difference when it comes to the future of non-harmful beauty.”

You can start by using the Think Dirty app, where you can scan beauty items and see any harmful ingredients they might contain, but until beauty brands are clear about what each ingredient does and its need to be in the bottle, clean beauty will always remain murky.

Keep On Reading

By Abby Amoakuh

Internet users dig up old clips of Yung Filly following the YouTuber’s arrest in Australia

By Louis Shankar

5 essential TV shows to watch before the chaos of the 2024 US presidential election

By Fleurine Tideman

Is the very demure, very mindful TikTok trend rife with misogyny or just silly, goofy fun?

By Abby Amoakuh

Did Stranger Things star David Harbour use celebrity dating app Raya to cheat on Lily Allen?

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

German island to scrap controversial Christmas tradition of hitting women brutally with cow horns

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Character.AI chatbots are targeting teens into anorexia with dangerous advice

By Charlie Sawyer

Cher Lloyd reveals she was told to seduce Justin Bieber when she was a teen

By Charlie Sawyer

From his beef with Taylor Swift to losing Justin Bieber’s loyalty, here’s why Scooter Braun is in his flop era

By Abby Amoakuh

Inside the alarming rise of teen radicalisation online: From chatrooms to the Vienna Taylor Swift concert terror suspect

By Joe Pettit

Why the internet made a CEO’s killer its new sex symbol

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Ready for an early career break? The microretirement trend is Gen Z’s new way of escaping job stress

By J'Nae Phillips

Corpcore and boardroom baddies: How Gen Z are reinventing office style

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show 2024 has haters and fans alike losing their mind, here’s why

By Abby Amoakuh

Size 8 model reveals she has to wear fat suits to model for plus-sized clothing

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

ShxtsNGigs face major backlash: When will comedians stop targeting Black women for cheap laughs?

By Abby Amoakuh

Young girls are being lured into drug trade with promises of botox, lip fillers, and makeup products

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Fans rally around Sabrina Carpenter after YouTuber Hannah Pearl Davis labels her catfish of the year

By Abby Amoakuh

It Ends With Us author Colleen Hoover’s long history of controversies and problematic behaviour

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Mark Zuckerberg criticised as Meta allegedly censors abortion pill providers, raising Trump alliance fears

By Abby Amoakuh

Who is Belle Gibson, the Australian scammer who inspired Netflix’s Apple Cider Vinegar?