James Charles asks for privacy, but can he?

By Tahmina Begum

Updated May 16, 2020 at 11:02 AM

Reading time: 3 minutes

If you are used to posting frequently across your social media channels, your Stories are always up to date and you’ve read and retweeted the funniest trending memes by noon today, you’ll know that as much as you’re putting out there, you are equally receiving back. And it’s not a Big Brother type scenario—it’s those you are endearingly commenting on their selfies saying “Sis” and referring to as “Auntie” online.

Now imagine you have nearly 11.5 million people watching you on both YouTube and Instagram. 2.3 million favouring your tweets and another nearly 200 hundred thousand liking your videos on Facebook alone. That is the cyber reality of 19-year-old makeup artist and beauty YouTuber James Charles.

Recognised across the internet for his thick brows, contoured (and highlighted to the gods) cheekbones and an advocate for boys wearing makeup, James Charles is also a CoverGirl, entertainer and has worked with the likes of other influential names such as Jeffree Star and Liza Koshy to name a few. But just like many other lifestyle YouTubers, Charles’ fame is based on his life—or the one he chooses to put out there. His makeup reviews and fun challenges on YouTube are one of the ways to get your fix of him; with his wider social media presence full of his day-to-day activities, outfits, events and the people in his life.

Charles is the nouveau kind of new money: his celebrity is based on doing makeup looks, from the relatable to the highly skilled art on one’s face, presented on the biggest global video sharing channel anyone can access. But with growth in recognition to millions and collaborations with celebrities such as Kim Kardashian, he’s gone from being attainable to aspirational in a matter of three years. Yet what Charles is selling is not just makeup or his views on taking down conventional beauty standards for men and women. Just like his contemporaries, the premise for how Charles truly makes his money comes from continuously sharing his personal life with the world. It does not come as a surprise then that the YouTube influencer is battling with his privacy offline.

Recently, Charles shared a tweet instructing fans not to visit his home following a frightening security breach. The tweet said “I will not hug you, I will not take a photo with you, and I absolutely will not sign your palette. It is extremely disrespectful & makes me feel very unsafe in my own home. Respect people’s privacy, it’s really not that hard”. Charles’ message seems clear—in conventional settings—but are the blurred lines really that easy to understand if a fundamental aspect of your fame is laid in sharing your private life with your fans, especially if a majority of them are Gen Z teenagers who have grown up with influencers like Charles as part of their norm?

Some would argue it’s contradictory for Charles to ask for privacy when he has made it his business to be so public and even built a career on welcoming the world into his life. For those wondering if he stopped posting frequently after asking for more privacy, of course, Charles couldn’t because this is technically his source of means. The beauty YouTuber continued with regular programming six hours after making his statement, which later went viral on Twitter (a modern-day Catch22 if we ever saw one). Surely the concept of privacy has changed if, on the one hand, you’d like to be left alone in your home and on the other hand, fans are greeted with “Hi Sisters!” from Charles’ bedroom on a daily basis.

The difference between Charles, as an influencer, asking for privacy and a celebrity with a profession such as acting, for example, is that an actor’s product is their character and films, whereas Charles is selling himself and his day-to-day life. Arguably, just like the Kardashians, the Jenners, or any other reality TV star, people should be granted privacy regardless of what they may be selling but actually, I believe this status quo of disregard to personal boundaries comes from an over familiarisation with these figures, which is innate to the influencer culture they are a part of.

In 1999, sponsored by the Screen Actors Guild, Hollywood actors legally were allowed the law of privacy after the tragic death of Diana, Princess of Wales. Is it time then for this law to be amended as influencers such as James Charles have completely rehashed the definition of new entertainment, with many YouTubers and influencers also struggling to maintain their privacy While the majority of Charles’ audience clearly respects his personal space (as it’s only the odd one or two followers who showed up at his home and not 11 million), privacy becomes extremely hard to attain when it looks like you already have the world over for dinner.

Keep On Reading

By Abby Amoakuh

BBC presenter apologises after giving the middle finger to audience mid-broadcast

By Charlie Sawyer

New cancer-killing pill could completely eradicate tumours from patients’ bodies

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Colleen Ballinger’s ukulele video is peak cringe YouTuber apology

By Charlie Sawyer

How to get a refund on your student loan from SLC

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Suella Braverman’s lifestyle choice remark sparks outrage amid growing homelessness crisis

By Alma Fabiani

50 Cent is sponsoring an under-14 girls football team in Wales

By Malavika Pradeep

What is HuCow? A dairy queen explains the lactation fetish that imagines women as human cows

By Charlie Sawyer

TikToker reveals the underwhelming food served at the White House Pride event

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Watch Ron DeSantis get booed off stage at a vigil for Jacksonville shooting victims

By Abby Amoakuh

Tory Crispin Blunt might be the latest MP accused of sexual misconduct, but he isn’t the first

By Charlie Sawyer

Your favourite author has been labelled as anti-trans (and no, we’re not talking about JK Rowling)

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Let Ron be Ron: Presidential candidate Ron DeSantis makes shocking claims about slavery

By Alma Fabiani

Machine Gun Kelly confronts stage-storming fan and apologises for primal reaction

By Alma Fabiani

The Summer I Turned Pretty season 2 finale: Is a bonus episode or part 2 on the way?

By Charlie Sawyer

The death of independent media. VICE may have been the first victim, but it won’t be the last

By Charlie Sawyer

Watch this video of Luigi ruining a wedding proposal at Super Nintendo World

By Alma Fabiani

Watch the absolutely bonkers trailer for sloth horror movie Slotherhouse

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Spanish reporter groped on live TV confronts man and has him arrested

By Fleurine Tideman

I love you Barbie, but we need Feral Women Media now more than ever

By Louis Shankar

Sorry everyone, but Saltburn is a car crash of a film