How women and queer people helped topple Puerto Rico’s corrupt government

By Laura Box

Updated May 19, 2020 at 03:46 PM

Reading time: 3 minutes

Puerto Rico’s feminist and queer-led protests and the subsequent ousting of Governor Ricardo Rosselló and Chief Financial Officer Christian Sobrino have demonstrated the power of oppressed groups in orchestrating significant change. The demonstrations in San Juan act as a timely reminder for queer communities not to lose sight of the need to protest, especially in months following the most corporatised and ‘pinkwashed’ Pride celebrations in history.

The protests came in light of leaked conversations from a telegram chat spanning 889 pages between Rosselló and his closest advisors, including Sobrino, and various other high-powered current and former Puerto Rican politicians. The discussion contained homophobic, misogynist and classist messages, as well as jokes about victims of Hurricane Maria.

The Colectiva Feminista en Construcción, a Puerto Rican feminist collective (that gained international notice for their help in the Hurricane Maria recovery) were early convenors of the march. In November before the leaks, the collective had protested at the government residence for three days, urging Rosselló—who didn’t attend—to call a state of emergency and address the significant problem of gender violence on the island. “Now we know why he didn’t want to meet with us, now we know why they keep murdering, assaulting, raping, abusing, harassing women in this country with impunity; because whoever directs the country is the first to violate us”, said spokesperson Dávila Roldán in Spanish.

Ricky Martin, who was mocked in the messages, also called for Rosselló to cede his position and urged his fellow nationals to join him in protest. “We cannot allow our Puerto Rico to be in the hands of such ‘leaders’”, Martin wrote on Twitter in Spanish. “This is NOT the government we need. This is NOT the Puerto Rico that our grandparents and parents built, much less the one we want to leave to our children”.

The messages, one from Puerto Rico’s Chief Financial Officer Christian Sobrino, who has since resigned, called Martin sexist because he is gay. “Nothing says patriarchal oppression like Ricky Martin”, Sobrino wrote. “Ricky Martin is such a male chauvinist that he fucks men because women don’t measure up. Pure patriarchy”. Ricky Martin took to the streets on Wednesday, July 17, to lead protestors in San Juan, waving a pride flag above the crowd. The leaked messages also included jokes about shooting women in power, called other male politicians and journalists they disagreed with “cocksuckers” and fat-shamed a senator.

When the leaders of a country are caught expressing disdain for their citizens—and not just for one persecuted group, but many—they inevitably take the role of the oppressor. For Puerto Rico, this led to a rare example of national unification, bringing together people of all political inclinations. The influence of the feminist organisers and Ricky Martin’s significant reach, both in the LGBTQ+ community and beyond, undeniably helped unite the hundreds of thousands of protestors in the eight days following the leak, making it clear that there was no space for the antiquated boys clubs on the island.

Internationally, these protests act as a reminder in the months after the most corporatised Pride in history of the real reason that queer people have protested in the past.  

Global corporations, from international banks to fast fashion brands, have become present in Pride celebrations globally. For these businesses, the decision to join the 2019 Pride celebrations is a no brainer: with gay marriage legalised and queer representation in pop culture increasing, the chance of negative business impact is unlikely. Furthermore, the LGBTQ+ community has proven to be one of the most loyal markets for brands to obtain, meaning the incentive is obvious: be seen as progressive, while improving business prospects.

But where were these businesses 20 years ago? Even six years ago, when same sex marriage wasn’t legal in the U.K., the U.S., and most EU countries? Participating in a protest only once the protest is seen as socially acceptable reduces the legitimacy of both the protest and your involvement. 

While some have argued that Pride isn’t about the protest anymore, but that it’s about the celebration of the rights queer people have attained, as long as there are still trans people being murdered, intersex children being forced into genital cosmetic surgeries, and parents rejecting their queer children, we must protest.

So when the leaders of Puerto Rico are recorded making homophobic comments, however small, and transphobic comments, however privately, it serves as a reiteration of the need to legitimately fight for the rights of queer people, as well as other minorities.

These protests were a mirror to the first protests for queer rights and acted as a contrast to modern Pride: Rather than following a government approved, rule-bound schedule, Puerto Ricans took the power into their own hands to protest homophobia and corporate corruption (after two politicians were caught directing $15.5 million to favoured businesses, which seems all the more relevant in light of the corporate influence in the 2019 pride celebrations).

In order for the voices of minorities to be heard, protests need to be angry, driven, and not motivated by a capitalist agenda. Corporations and politicians’ agendas should be the object of criticism—not centre stage. A women and queer-led march toppled the corrupt, homophobic, and sexist Puerto Rican government; maybe this was 2019’s real pride.

Keep On Reading

By Alma Fabiani

Worst London tube lines and stations for air pollution exposed in worrying research

By Alma Fabiani

The rise of CringeTok and the end of coolness

By Jennifer Raymont

15 Instagram-approved jewellery bits to perfect your summer collection

By Abby Amoakuh

Black models boycott Melbourne Fashion Week to protest racial discrimination

By Jennifer Raymont

She must be a butch: Addressing the gender stereotypes surrounding female footballers’ fashion

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

French riots fuel far-right National Rally’s march into the mainstream. Why is no one reporting on it?

By Alma Fabiani

TikToker jailed in Indonesia for using Islamic phrase before eating pork

By Priya Raj

Fast fashion factories: Why are brands like Oh Polly and SHEIN pretending to be honest now?

By Charlie Sawyer

The Guardian claims Greta Gerwig sold her indie soul by directing Barbie

By Charlie Sawyer

The very best moments from Variety’s 2023 Actors on Actors series

By Alma Fabiani

Euphoria actor Angus Cloud dead aged 25. Here’s everything you need to know

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

MrBeast accused of bullying after he sues his own fast food chain MrBeast Burger

By Alma Fabiani

No bonus episode for The Summer I Turned Pretty. Watch cast react to season 2’s top scenes

By Emma O'Regan-Reidy

How LinkedIn has managed to appeal to four generations at once, gen Z included

By Abby Amoakuh

Gender pay gap denier gets paid £200 for Sky News debate on misogyny, female guest gets nothing

By Charlie Sawyer

Girl, 11, savagely attacked by American bully XL: Should the dog breed be banned?

By Emma O'Regan-Reidy

What is demi method makeup, and what’s its connection to an alleged MLM scam?

By Charlie Sawyer

Fancy staying in Shrek’s swamp? Well, here are Airbnb’s most iconic film-inspired homes

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Latest femicide in Italy sparks protests following reports of 102 women killed in 2023

By Alma Fabiani

Exploring AI trends: Advancements, impact, and future possibilities