Inside the Bibby Stockholm: A complex story of asylum seeker housing and human rights

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Published Aug 13, 2023 at 09:00 AM

Reading time: 3 minutes

In the port of Portland, South Dorset a 15 feet metal fencing and two guarded gates encircle a towering presence: The Bibby Stockholm. Standing as the Home Office’s first asylum seeker barge, this vessel arrived in Dorset three weeks ago, yet its empty interior bore a stark contrast to its imposing exterior. This week, it hosts its first occupants, as hundreds more are set to join them in the days ahead.

The Bibby Stockholm, a three-level barge, aims to accommodate asylum seekers, a group that has faced significant challenges and setbacks due to the COVID-19 pandemic. These individuals, many of whom have endured hardships in their pursuit of safety and a better life, now find themselves residing within cramped beige-walled cabins. Up to six people are expected to share each room, resulting in living spaces smaller than an average car parking bay.

@novaramedia

Asylum seekers don’t deserve this. The three-story ship the Bibby Stockholm arrived in Falmouth for a refit earlier this week. The boat will soon house 500 asylum seekers at a time while their applications are processed. #asylumseekers #refugees #tories #westminster #barge #falmouth #ukpolitics #politics

♬ original sound - Novara Media

While the barge may seem like a solution, its design raises concerns. The vessel’s security is rigid, with walk-through scanners and bag checks for entry and exit. Security personnel, including those with a military background, are present around the clock, preparing for a range of scenarios including disputes and fights. A secure compound confines inhabitants, allowing only shuttle buses to access the port exit for safety reasons. This structure is a reminder of the fragility of freedom.

Yet, as Amnesty International’s past report reveals, this isn’t the first time asylum seekers have been housed in such conditions. The Bibby Stockholm’s history is fraught with tragedy. Once used by the Dutch government in the 2000s, reports emerged of rape, abuse, and even death onboard. The memories of four people sharing a cell, enduring fights over basic amenities, and stifling conditions linger.

However, despite an internal health document’s multiple concerns about potential disease outbreaks on the Bibby Stockholm barge, ministers are persisting with the transfer of asylum seekers onto the vessel. The outbreak management plan, obtained through an NHS Dorset freedom of information request, underscores the risk of diseases like diphtheria, TB, legionnaires’ disease, norovirus, salmonella, and scabies.

This draft plan, composed by Home Office contractors Bibby Stockholm, Landry & Kling, and Global Ship Solutions, strongly underscores the necessity of surge staffing in the event of significant outbreaks. Meanwhile, lawyers representing asylum seekers are continuing to file last-minute legal challenges, arguing against the safety of using the barge as housing.

The recent comments by Lee Anderson, the deputy chair of the Conservative Party, further accentuate the dehumanising rhetoric often attached to asylum seekers. His callous suggestion to “f*** off back to France” undermines the complexities these individuals face and erodes the empathy we should extend.

While certain Tory MPs have privately voiced similar sentiments, the unease within ministerial circles remains largely hidden from the public eye. Justice Secretary Alex Chalk, for example, lauded Mr Anderson’s candid language, hailing it as a reflection of the nation’s “righteous indignation.”

Immigration Minister Robert Jenrick, known for his directive to remove a Mickey Mouse mural from a children’s asylum centre under the pretext of it not being “age-appropriate,” opted for a more measured response, asserting that “everyone chooses their own language.” However, he maintains that Mr Anderson’s point, a sentiment he aligns with, is indeed valid.

@gbnews

Lee Anderson has refused to apologise for telling migrants who refuse to board the Bibby Stockholm barge to 'f*** off back to France' #migrant #NigelFarage #LeeAnderson #migrantcrisis #BibbyStockholm #GBNews

♬ original sound - GB News

For those who arrived on this barge, their journeys have been marked by adversity. Many have fled conflict, survived torture, or escaped modern slavery. Placing them in cramped quarters resembling a “quasi-floating prison” may exacerbate their trauma and further dehumanise them. Resisting this environment, several asylum seekers have refused to board the Bibby Stockholm. Their choice speaks volumes about the fear instilled by this setting.

Amnesty International condemns using such vessels to house asylum seekers, emphasising their vulnerability in this context. The Bibby Stockholm, despite its appearances, signifies a failure in our commitment to compassion and human rights. The words we use in this discourse matter, for they shape perceptions and influence policies.

The past speaks to us, recalling how similar barges saw suffering and death in the past. This ominous present resonates with echoes from the 2000s, raising the question of whether we have truly learned from history. In the wake of Europe’s response to migration in that era, the use of such vessels did not just confine bodies, but crushed spirits and suppressed hope.

As the government presses on with these plans, aiming to fill the barge with 500 individuals, there are urgent concerns to address. The nature of this accommodation, rife with echoes of trauma, calls for profound reflection. The promise of cheaper solutions cannot justify compromising the dignity and well-being of vulnerable individuals.

As of now, the most recent breaking news has revealed that Legionella bacteria, which can cause a serious type of lung infection known as Legionnaires’ disease, has been found in the water on the barge only four days after individuals began boarding. Emergency evacuation has commenced, as reported by Sky News.

The Bibby Stockholm stands not just as a vessel in a harbour, but as a testament to our ethical compass. The impact on these lives, their futures, and the message we send to the world carries a weight we must acknowledge. It is not enough to merely house bodies, we must recognise the humanity, potential, and dreams that reside within them.

Keep On Reading

By Yair Oded

Backlash breaks as Brunei passes new laws that violate human rights

By Moss Tawny

What happens when human provenance is used to determine immigration rights?

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

UK gov needs to recreate Homes for Ukraine scheme for Sudanese refugees, says campaign founder

By Charlie Sawyer

Ghislaine Maxwell breaks silence on newly unsealed Jeffrey Epstein court documents

By Charlie Sawyer

Legit or not? Debunking the latest viral £50 Temu free money giveaway

By Charlie Sawyer

Michelle Troconis found guilty of conspiring with late boyfriend to murder his estranged wife Jennifer Dulos

By Lois Freeman

The ugly path to freedom: How I finally ended my teenage eating disorder

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Zara faces boycott as controversial advert draws comparisons to Israel-Hamas war scenes

By Abby Amoakuh

Barron Trump is being groomed to take over the Trump empire and the graduation fuss proves it

By Charlie Sawyer

Megan Fox accused of xenophobia after comparing bad photo of herself to Ukrainian blowup doll

By Abby Amoakuh

BBC presenter apologises after giving the middle finger to audience mid-broadcast

By Abby Amoakuh

MGK opens up about miscarriage with Megan Fox after couple’s short-lived break-up

By Charlie Sawyer

New York Attorney General sues some of the US’ biggest pro-life groups for unsafe Abortion Pill Reversal treatment

By Fleurine Tideman

PETA joins team Ariana against Tom Sandoval ahead of Vanderpump Rules season 11

By Charlie Sawyer

Michael J. Fox speech at the BAFTA Awards 2024 leaves viewers in tears

By Charlie Sawyer

Will the TikTok ban push Gen Z into the arms of Donald Trump?

By Abby Amoakuh

Nikki Haley pushes ahead of Ron DeSantis as Chris Christie drops out of presidential race

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Amanda Bynes reveals recent cosmetic surgery on her eyelids in viral TikTok

By Charlie Sawyer

Republican lawmaker censured for saying mass shootings are god’s punishment for abortion rights

By Abby Amoakuh

Fans campaign for Jonathan Majors’ Marvel comeback after actor avoids prison in domestic violence case