Opinion

What is an artificial womb and can it work for humans?

By Tasmin Lockwood

Updated May 18, 2020 at 05:02 PM

Reading time: 3 minutes


Human rights

Mar 26, 2020

6133

In 2017, when a premature lamb was successfully grown to term inside an artificial womb, a ‘bio bag’, spectators argued that human fetuses would be next. In October 2019, Dutch researchers were awarded €2.9 million to develop a prototype. In a time of a pandemic where everyone is affected and people fear for their life, could artificial wombs represent a glimpse of hope for a better future?

Unlike existing incubators that provide artificial respiration, this technology simulates the biological environment and feeds the fetus oxygen and nutrients through tubes, in the same way the placenta and umbilical cord do. This would allow premature babies, whose lungs are often not developed enough to breathe air and have high mortality rates to grow to term outside the uterus, which is the largest supporting argument for the technology.

“Artificial wombs will help babies born prematurely survive. That’s the main help,” Zolton Istvan, a transhumanist figurehead running in the 2020 US presidential election as a Republican, told Screen Shot. “This is an intrinsic part of the transhumanist movement since it will use radical science to change an existing institution of humanity,” he added.

What is an artificial womb and can it work for humans?

Artificial wombs could eliminate risks associated with pregnancy and childbirth although, currently, the mother is still an integral part of the birthing process—an embryo cannot be fertilised and planted in an artificial womb, first it must be partially grown inside a uterus. If this was possible, it would be what is called ectogenesis.

“It will also give women a third choice when it comes to abortion. Instead of aborting, they can have the fetus transplanted into an artificial womb,” Istvan added. “There’s a lot of fighting between pro-life and pro-choice, having a third choice regarding abortion will ease society’s divisiveness.” Terminating a pregnancy without having to end the life of the child presents vast social and ethical questions, such as an increased pressure on the state to provide the necessary equipment and resources. In 2018, there were 205,295 abortions in England and Wales.

Speaking to Screen Shot, Elizabeth Chloe Romanis, a lawyer and bioethicist at the University of Manchester, explains that “Access to choices in pregnancy are subject to lots of social, legal and medical control and we need to make sure that the artificial womb is not used to deny women access to reproductive healthcare like abortion.”

Although technology is not yet advanced enough for ectogenesis, many see bio bags, which could hinder female autonomy, as a stepping stone. Removing the natural dependency on women to have children could be integral in achieving true gender equality and balanced parenting. As a result of this, what it means to be a mother could be redefined.

At its very basic level, the technology would mean women no longer have to leave their jobs or go through labour, both things which Ivstan sees as positives. If neither parent was tied to a child physically, maternity and paternity leave would potentially equalise.

Giulia Cavaliere, a lecturer specialising in bioethics and reproductive technology at Lancaster Medical School, agrees with the fact that artificial wombs will allow women to become mothers “in the same ways as men became fathers,” by “enjoying all the positive stuff while not experiencing any of the negative physical, psychological, professional and personal effects.”

She added: “There are also other benefits; women who could not or would not want to gestate and birth children could still be able to have genetically related children. A society where women are less subjected to health-related risks is a better society.” This would be particularly impactful for women without a uterus, male same-sex couples and single males.

Itsvan explained that it is likely that women’s pay will increase as a result of the technology, because “women’s careers won’t be interrupted.” At the moement, growing embryos into babies outside of a womb is restricted legally and technologically, with no evidence an embryo can be taken to term from scratch with current bio bags, and it being illegal to do so.

Instead, legal definitions and potential backlash to existing functionalities must be managed. Romanis explained that “what is most interesting is how this will change some of our ideas about birth. A subject in an artificial womb is not completely born, even though they have been delivered from their mother, because they are still undergoing gestation and are not interacting with the external environment. The social response is hard to predict. Should we treat it like a foetus, or like a born baby?”

Regulation will play a part in this, determining whether artificial wombs are restricted for medical use. While “depicted as freedom and equality-promoting for all women,” as Romanis said, if used generally bio pregnancies could exaggerate class divide with fewer middle-class couples opting for natural pregnancy or, on the contrary, it could see vulnerable mothers who smoke, take drugs or are from a minority group being coerced into using the technology.

If artificial wombs become an option in the near future, it remains uncertain whether women will opt for it without good reasons as Romanis highlighted how invasive the procedure would be. Although it is facing important financial, technological and legal hurdles, the continued development of this niche health tech no doubt holds the key to both true gender equality and widespread social controversy. As controversial as they are, artificial wombs are also something exciting to look out for in the near future—a positive thing to think about while stuck at home.

Keep On Reading

By Abby Amoakuh

Jenna Ortega deleted X after receiving pictures of nudes and underaged deepfake porn of herself

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

TikTokers rally behind Simu Liu after he calls out bubble tea whitewashing on Dragon’s Den

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Children as young as 14 participate in feral cat-killing competition, leaving over 300 animals dead

By J'Nae Phillips

Cyber nostalgia: How Gen Z-coded Y3K fashion is going to shape the future

By Emma O'Regan-Reidy

Will the underconsumption core TikTok trend change influencing for good?

By Charlie Sawyer

Outrage as male students rip up Australia campus sexual violence report in viral video

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Tradwife influencer Nara Smith accused of stealing content by South African TikToker Onezwa Mbola

By Abby Amoakuh

Woman gets fired after getting pregnant again while on maternity leave

By Charlie Sawyer

What is a spicy cruise? Here’s why swinging culture is taking over TikTok

By Abby Amoakuh

Democratic National Convention 2024: The Obamas bring the house down and Gus Walz proudly cries

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Trump-appointed judge faces backlash over viral video exposing her opinions on dwarf tossing

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Was the alleged assassination attempt on Trump staged? Conspiracy theorists think so

By Charlie Sawyer

Are tradwives out? How Levi Coralynn is spearheading the rise of provider women

By Abby Amoakuh

Reese Witherspoon reveals upcoming Legally Blonde prequel series

By Abby Amoakuh

Sex workers in the UK say the financial institutions are waging a war against them

By Abby Amoakuh

Katy Perry responds to backlash after working with alleged abuser on Woman’s World

By Charlie Sawyer

Girl who charges $70 to test people’s boyfriends’ loyalty reveals 90% usually fail

By Abby Amoakuh

Sexual assault and self-harm in women’s jails skyrocket as prisons become too overcrowded

By Louis Shankar

None of the UK political parties’ manifestos offer proper protection for the LGBTQIA+ community

By Charlie Sawyer

Famous British athlete wishes rapist Steven van de Velde best of luck ahead of Paris 2024 Olympics