Nearly half of new mums think about harming their baby, research reveals

By Malavika Pradeep

Published Mar 21, 2022 at 12:31 PM

Reading time: 3 minutes

What are some of the most common pieces of advice you’ve heard being tossed around to newbie parents? ‘Cherish every moment because babies grow up fast’? Or maybe ‘Always trust your gut’? How about ‘At some point, you’re going to imagine throwing your baby against the wall. Don’t do it’?

Let’s be honest here, we’re raised in a culture that portrays parenting as a magical experience, but the reality is a lot more stressful and concerning. Parenthood comes with a load of confusion, zero sleep, random diaper blowouts, constant wailing and your own hormones on a perpetual rollercoaster themselves. This may induce negative or even violent thoughts like: What if I drop the baby from the staircase? What if I drive off the road with them?

Believe it or not, a vast majority of parents experience such unwanted intrusive thoughts (UITs). Now, Doctor Nichole Fairbrother, psychologist and clinical associate professor at the UBC Island Medical Program, has concluded the statistics on the natural phenomenon with her colleagues.

In the study, researchers conducted phone interviews with new mothers from across Canada at both nine and 21 weeks postpartum. They then used a semi-structured interview protocol, called the Postpartum Intrusions Interview (PII), to assess their mental health and the prevalence of UITs. The categories included thoughts, impulses or images that pop into the participants’ minds.

Out of the 340 newbie mothers interviewed, 151 (about 44 per cent) reported experiencing thoughts of intentionally harming their babies. “These findings are not an anomaly,” Big Think went on to explain. “They are consistent with prior research estimating that between 20 per cent and 50 per cent of new mothers and fathers experience intrusive thoughts of intentionally harming their newborns.” Say what?

So, should we actually be worried about the safety of newborns when they’re in the hands of their own parents? To analyse if UITs translate into physical harm, Fairbrother and her team subjected participants to a questionnaire that included lists of physical aggression like shaking, hitting, spanking, burning and choking their infant.

To encourage complete disclosure, the newbie mothers were repeatedly informed that their answers would be kept anonymous. “We went to great lengths to ensure that maternal reports of aggression towards their infant could be reported anonymously and that our participants knew this,” Fairbrother noted. “Even the researchers [themselves] were unable to go back and link reports of maternal aggression to the participant’s identity.”

The verdict? Out of the 151 women who reported having thoughts of intentional harm, only four (2.6 per cent) admitted to actually behaving aggressively towards their newborn. The same rate among the rest 189 participants stood at 3.2 per cent, where six mothers reported having thoughts of intentional physical harm, even though they didn’t have UITs. Simply put, thoughts don’t always lead to actions.

One case where UITs did result in aggression involved 35-year-old nurse anaesthetist and mother of two, Krista Noelle Madden. On 8 May 2019, Madden called the police and reported that she and her infant daughter had been kidnapped from their upscale neighbourhood by two masked strangers. While the mother managed to escape, she said that the kidnappers still had her newborn baby.

However, the investigation took a wild turn when seven-week-old Shaylie was found bruised but alive—dumped about 30 feet down a steep ravine. Authorities later confirmed that Madden herself had thrown the baby over the edge.

Nearly half of new mums think about harming their baby, research reveals

After the mother was charged with first-degree attempted murder, the public swiftly flooded Madden’s Facebook page with comments labelling her “demonic” and threatening her to be tortured and killed. But Madden’s attorney pointed out how the mother was a victim after all, not of masked kidnappers perhaps, but of her own mind. While Madden was transferred to a specialty psychiatric facility in Chapel Hill, the publicised case sparked conversation about the severe mental health conditions that most mothers face, but know dangerously little about.

While Fairbrother and her team are currently conducting a large-scale replication study by enrolling thousands of new mothers, it should be noted that UITs tend to arise in almost every emotional situation that elicits frustration or fear. “Say, for example, that you are afraid of flying. When boarding an aeroplane, then you might imagine every terrible thing that could happen,” Big Think mentioned, adding how the key here is to avoid worrying and obsessing over these thoughts. “If you are a new parent experiencing thoughts of harming your infant, you probably do not need to worry about your child. Instead, give yourself a break and take care of your own wellbeing.”

Fairbrother additionally noted how our society often puts parenthood and infant safety on a pedestal, in turn, making such topics taboo. “As a result, parents can feel very afraid that these thoughts mean something terrible about them,” she explained. “Our findings should be a relief to many.”

Keep On Reading

By Abby Amoakuh

Jeffrey Epstein flight logs: Prince Andrew controversy resurfaces as nearly 200 names to be released

By Abby Amoakuh

Trump to face trial in hush money case, as Fani Willis defends romantic relationship in Georgia case 

By Bianca Borissova

What role did Mormons, momfluencers and pre-teen girls play in the current Stanley Cup craze?

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

ISIS started trending on X after the terrorist group allegedly threatened to attack Champions League

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Miriam Margolyes angers adult Harry Potter fans after saying they need to grow up

By Alma Fabiani

What is a nepo baby, and why do they make everyone so mad?

By Abby Amoakuh

Grave site for Megan Thee Stallion’s mother ramps up security after Nicki Minaj fans leak location

By Abby Amoakuh

Oklahoma State Senator Dusty Deevers to criminalise watching porn with penalties of up to 20 years in prison

By Abby Amoakuh

RuPaul’s new online bookstore Allstore removes anti-trans and far-right books following controversy

By Louis Shankar

Nex Benedict’s tragic death proves the US and UK have learnt nothing about inclusivity in schools

By Emma O'Regan-Reidy

Is BookTok ruining reading? Critics seem to think so

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Report reveals psychiatric hospital allegedly forced patients to reuse menstrual pads for days

By Charlie Sawyer

Kim Kardashian faces backlash for shocking two word response to Palestine protester

By Charlie Sawyer

Tucker Carlson pranked by YouTuber pretending to be Kate Middleton whistleblower 

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

NHS starts testing weight loss pill with gastric balloon inside for the first time

By Abby Amoakuh

What is girl therapy? The TikTok trend disguising middle-class consumerism as self-care to Gen Z

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Former boy band member accuses Taylor Swift of performing demonic rituals at concerts

By Charlie Sawyer

Home Office to pay TikTok influencers up to £5K to warn migrants not to cross the Channel

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

From its lack of popularity with young voters to the Nikki Haley wild card, the GOP has had a tough week

By Fleurine Tideman

PETA joins team Ariana against Tom Sandoval ahead of Vanderpump Rules season 11