Canadian police forced to remove DNA-generated suspect image following racial profiling accusations

By Charlie Sawyer

Published Oct 10, 2022 at 05:21 PM

Reading time: 2 minutes

37059

A Canadian police department has recently come under fire after they tweeted a DNA-assisted image of a potential suspect. The computer-generated image was based on a profile of DNA recovered from a victim involved in a sexual assault case from 2019. It depicted a young black man, approximately 25, with short hair and a neutral expression.

According to CBC, the mugshot, released on 4 October 2022 by the Edmonton Police Section (EPS), was produced by Parabon NanoLabs, a forensic genetics company that has been shrouded in controversy ever since it began to facilitate DNA profiling and phenotyping—the activity or process of determining, analysing, or predicting all or part of an organism’s traits.

In 2019, Parabon’s Snapshot tool rose to prominence. The analysis service was developed to help police “provide a comprehensive analysis of someone’s ancestry and a composite facial sketch from a DNA sample,” as stated by Nature.

However, multiple experts in genetics have warned of the racial biases that may be perpetuated through the use of such technology. Sociologist Helena Machado is one such individual, telling Nature, “It might reinforce the idea that there is a higher prevalence of criminality in certain families.”

Yet, a quick scroll through Parabon’s website shows the company promising supposed law enforcement visitors, “Solve your toughest cases—FAST!”

Speaking on the use of Snapshot, Benedikt Hallgrimsson, head of cell biology and anatomy at the University of Calgary, told The New York Times, it’s “all a bit of science fiction at this point.” “Those of us working in the field in the genetics of facial shape don’t actually know how the company is doing their predictions,” Hallgrímsson went on to tell CBC.

Despite these major concerns, Parabon currently services dozens of police departments around the world, including Calgary, Saskatoon, Sudbury and Windsor. Clearly, law enforcement does not appreciate the serious concerns regarding this controversial technique—or do they?

Within the original post, which featured the DNA-assisted image, the EPS claimed that the tool would be a helpful measure to predict—not identify, just predict—what the criminal suspect might look like, as reported by Futurism.

Racial profiling is not a new problem, and rather than it depreciating in recent years, it has intensified in a number of ways. More aggressive bias-based policing has impacted swathes of people of colour. Only recently, on 5 September 2022, Chris Kaba—an unarmed black man—was fatally shot by the Metropolitan Police department. As of 4 October, it has been confirmed that Kaba was not a suspect before he was shot and killed. Rather, he was pursued by an unmarked police car without lights or sirens, as reported by The Guardian.

Surely a police department would realise the magnitude of releasing such an image, and indeed the problems that could arise for a number of men who may happen to resemble the alleged perpetrator.

Following mass criticism online, the EPS apologised and removed the image from its social media and website—nevertheless, the damage had already been done and many began to question why, knowing the flaws of DNA profiling, law enforcement would use such underdeveloped and problematic technology.

One geneticist, Dr Adam Rutherford, voiced his concerns directly to the EPS tweet, posting: “Geneticist here. You can’t make facial profiles or accurate pigmentation predictions from DNA, and this is dangerous snake oil.”

According to CBC, in a news conference held two days after the initial image was released to the public, Edmonton police chief Dale McFee—while he did support the decision to take down the image—stated, “We have to be very clear that when there’s nothing left [to do], we’ve got to unturn every stone.”

Enyinnah Okere, chief operating officer for the community safety and well-being bureau of EPS, also released a statement to the public: “Any time we use a new technology—especially one that does raise concerns about profiling of a marginalised group—we cannot be careful enough in how we validate these efforts and fully, transparently consider the risks.”

The statement continued: “While the tension I felt over this was very real, I prioritised the investigation—which in this case involved the pursuit of justice for the victim, herself a member of a racialized community, over the potential harm to the black community. This was not an acceptable trade-off and I apologise for this.”

Keep On Reading

By Charlie Sawyer

From performing at Mother Teresa’s canonization to 10+ film roles, no one works as hard as Rita Ora’s agent

By Charlie Sawyer

Why has the new sculpture of a Black American woman in Times Square prompted mass outrage?

By Abby Amoakuh

Tiktoker gets slammed by dermatologists for promoting dangerous caveman skincare regime

By Charlie Sawyer

Madison Beer opens up about reconnecting with the person who leaked her explicit photos as a teen

By Charlie Sawyer

How rediscovering Nintendogs as an adult has helped my anxiety

By Abby Amoakuh

New video game that allows men to r*pe female family members triggers backlash amid incel concerns

By Charlie Sawyer

Will Greta Thunberg reach Gaza safely amid Israel’s aid blockade?

By Charlie Sawyer

How influencer Liv Schmidt promotes toxic eating habits through the Skinni Société 

By Charlie Sawyer

Trump grants white South Africans refuge after ending legal protections for Afghans facing deportation

By Eliza Frost

Why do people want a nose like the Grinch? The Whoville TikTok trend explained

By Abby Amoakuh

BLACKPINK’s Lisa faces backlash after wearing civil rights icon Rosa Parks on her crotch at Met Gala

By Charlie Sawyer

Harry Potter TV series crew bewildered over production’s strange decision on location to film iconic scene

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Australian erotic novelist charged with child abuse material offenses after backlash over latest book

By Charlie Sawyer

Mexican beauty influencer Valeria Marquez killed during TikTok livestream in alleged femicide

By Abby Amoakuh

Gisèle Pelicot trial prompts French politicians to incorporate consent in rape law after years of resistence

By Charlie Sawyer

McDonald’s hit with new mass boycott. Here’s who’s behind it and why

By Eliza Frost

How Jet2holidays and Jess Glynne became the sound of the summer

By Abby Amoakuh

From dinner parties to grocery flexing: Inside Gen Z’s new language of luxury

By Abby Amoakuh

Sydney Sweeney calls wedding off and consciously uncouples from fiancé Jonathan Davino

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

James Toback hit with landmark $1.68 billion jury award after 40 women accused director of sexual abuse