Real or Spiel: the first online lie detector is here

By Yair Oded

Updated May 19, 2020 at 01:54 PM

Reading time: 3 minutes

1115

In nearly three decades on this earth, I’ve encountered (and slept with) a fair share of liars. Be it my hopeless naivete or general absentmindedness, I always feel thunderstruck by the revelation of their deceitful ways, which tend to cost a great deal of frustration, heartache, or, in some cases, money. Now, thanks to a new study by Florida State University (FSU) and Stanford researchers, it may be possible to identify such liars early on and spare ourselves the eventual catastrophe through an online lie-detector.

This beta incarnation of what is intended to become a bona fide virtual polygraph, utilises algorithms to decipher truth from lies while observing online conversations between two people—based solely on the content and speed of typing. Yet, an examination by WIRED reveals that numerous academics and machine learning experts raise serious concerns about this so-called lie detector and the social, economic, and personal implications such an invention might have.

In their experiment, the FSU and Stanford researchers had 40 participants play a game called ‘Real or Spiel’, in which paired individuals would answer each other’s questions either as lying ‘sinners’ or truth-telling ‘saints’. The researchers then used the content of the conversations and the pace and timing of each response in order to train a machine learning model to identify ‘sinners’ from ‘saints’—which they claim to have done with 82.5 percent accuracy. The researchers also state that they found liars exhibited more negative emotions and anxiety than saints, and produced faster and longer responses, replete with words such as “always” and “never”.

“The results were amazingly promising, and that’s the foundation of the online polygraph,” says one of the researchers to Computers in Human Behavior, “You could use it for online dating, Facebook, Twitter—the applications are endless.”

Critics, however, seriously doubt the ability of such a model to function as a reliable lie-detector device, and warn that a malfunction of such an invention could bear catastrophic ramifications on people’s lives and on society as a whole. In an interview for WIRED, Jevin West, a professor at the Information School at the University of Washington, says, “It’s an eye-catching result. But when you’re dealing with humans we have to be extra careful, especially when the implications of whether someone’s lying could lead to conviction, censorship, the loss of a job. When people think the technology has these abilities, the implications are bigger than a study.”

Kate Crawford, the co-founder of the AI Now Institute at New York University, seconds West’s scepticism and goes on to question the very methodology of the study. “You’re looking at linguistic patterns of people playing a game, and that’s very different from the way people really speak in daily life,” says Crawford to WIRED. She then draws a connection between this study to what she sees as a problematic history of polygraph tests, which produce scientifically questionable results and often render false positives.

As demonstrated by West and Crawford, there’s a litany of concerns regarding FSU and Stanford’s current study and its possible implications. But even if a more reliable virtual polygraph study were to surface—is this truly a technology we should be espousing?  

Yes, it could potentially constitute a useful tool to tackle false information circulating online or call out politicians on their untruthful Tweets. Even in day-to-day life, identifying lies could help us avoid scams, eliminate toxic relationships, and win court battles. Yet, a polygraph-on-the-go could also prove to be destructive, and for reasons other than those put forth by West and Crawford. One of them is the fact that, whether we care to admit it or not, we all engage in different degrees of lying, whether by telling our bestie that their new poem rocks or choosing to conceal our true location from a potentially creepy person we met on Grindr. The truth is that, often, a fib can be life-altering, and not necessarily in a negative sense.

As researchers and institutions across the globe race to forge the world’s first virtual lie-detector, major questions still linger: is an algorithm genuinely equipped to decipher dishonesty? What would its errors cost us? Is it always possible to strictly define a lie? And, are we truly ready to face the truth?

Besides, if we were to get the nitty-gritty of things, we’d realise that truth can be subjective, dynamic, and up for interpretation—particularly when it comes to emotions and opinions. Sometimes, exposure to the ‘truth’ can cause unnecessary pain and conflict. There is a reason we construct certain bubbles of illusion—and perhaps some of them aren’t meant to be burst.  

Keep On Reading

By Charlie Sawyer

The #MeToo movement is at risk. How the Harvey Weinstein retrial risks doing unimaginable damage 

By Eliza Frost

We finally know why Conrad and Belly broke up in The Summer I Turned Pretty season 2

By Abby Amoakuh

Tiktoker gets slammed by dermatologists for promoting dangerous caveman skincare regime

By Abby Amoakuh

BLACKPINK’s Lisa faces backlash after wearing civil rights icon Rosa Parks on her crotch at Met Gala

By Charlie Sawyer

Lawmakers pressure Trump to provide evidence that Venezuelan asylum seeker Andry Hernández Romero is still alive

By Eliza Frost

Sabrina Carpenter says you need to get out more if you think Man’s Best Friend artwork is controversial 

By Charlie Sawyer

New study confirms Bacterial Vaginosis can be sexually transmitted, backing what women have long suspected

By Charlie Sawyer

Donald trump to accept $400M luxury plane from Qatar royal family

By Charlie Sawyer

First look at $1 billion UK mini city where controversial HBO Harry Potter series will be filmed

By Eliza Frost

The Summer I Turned Pretty stars Lola Tung and Gavin Casalegno caught in political drama

By Eliza Frost

Jennifer Lawrence weighs in on The Summer I Turned Pretty love triangle, revealing she is Team Jeremiah

By Eliza Frost

Bad timing? Gavin Casalegno’s Dunkin’ ad sparks backlash over actor’s alleged conservative views

By Charlie Sawyer

UK government’s new murder prediction tool draws comparison to Tom Cruise film, Minority Report

By Charlie Sawyer

This Oscar-winning actor is the top pick to play Voldemort in HBO Max Harry Potter reboot

By Eliza Frost

Does the SKIMS Face Wrap actually work, or is it just another TikTok trap?

By Eliza Frost

How to spot a performative male out in the wild 

By Charlie Sawyer

What is ketamine therapy, the psychiatric treatment healing famous Mormons Jen and Zac Affleck’s marriage?

By Charlie Sawyer

Will Greta Thunberg reach Gaza safely amid Israel’s aid blockade?

By Matilda Ferraris

From Ballerina Cappuccina to Trallalero Trallalà, we unpack the darker undertones of Italian brainrot

By Charlie Sawyer

Gavin Casalegno cancelled? The Summer I Turned Pretty fans turn on him amid cast drama