I had to sign away my freedom to tell their story: A photojournalist on documenting Afghan women under the Taliban

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Published Dec 7, 2024 at 09:00 AM

Reading time: 3 minutes

64157

On 21 August 2024, the Taliban intensified their oppressive measures against Afghan women by implementing a new ‘Morality law’ that prohibits women from speaking or showing their faces in public. This decree, enforced by the Ministry for the Propagation of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice, mandates that women remain silent outside their homes, effectively erasing their presence from public life. The United Nations (UN) was quick to condemn this policy, describing it as “a distressing vision of Afghanistan’s future.”

But how did we get here? Well, this law is part of a broader pattern of escalating restrictions on women’s rights in Afghanistan. Since regaining power on 15 August 2021, the Taliban have systematically dismantled the most vulnerable members of society’s access to education and employment. Girls have been banned from secondary schools since March 2022 and women were suspended from universities in December of the same year. Additionally, women have been barred from most forms of employment, including roles in non-governmental organisations and international agencies.

In response to the ongoing human rights crisis in Afghanistan, Amnesty International has condemned the lack of action taken by the international community. As Samira Hamidi, Regional Campaigner for South Asia at Amnesty International, stated: “Three years on, the absolute absence of any concrete measures in addressing the human rights catastrophe in Afghanistan is a source of shame for the world.”

In this harrowing context, SCREENSHOT had the privilege of sitting down with Valentina Sinis, a remarkable documentary photographer whose work brings to light the lives of the unseen and unheard. We previously spoke to Sinis about another highly important topic: Iraqi Kurdistan women burning themselves as a form of escape from domestic violence or an expression of extreme despair.

And now, the photojournalist has taken on another deeply challenging investigative journey into Afghanistan, seeking to uncover the human stories behind the Taliban’s relentless crackdown on women.

I had to sign away my freedom to tell their story: A photojournalist on documenting Afghan women under the Taliban

To gain access to Afghanistan, Sinis faced immense challenges and was required to sign a contract dictating her movements, interactions, and subjects of documentation. Despite these restrictions, her unwavering commitment to shedding light on the plight of Afghan women propelled her forward.

Through her lens, Valentina captured the quiet courage, heartbreaking resilience, and determined acts of defiance that define the lives of women under Taliban rule. Her work provides a raw and unflinching portrait of the women who refuse to be silenced, even as oppressive policies seek to erase them from public life.

I had to sign away my freedom to tell their story: A photojournalist on documenting Afghan women under the Taliban

My conversation with photo journalist Valentina Sinis

What motivated you to travel to Afghanistan, despite the current restrictions and risks?

Afghanistan’s unfolding story under Taliban rule is one of the most significant global developments. Despite the risks, documenting the realities, especially the plight of women and marginalised groups, is crucial to inform the world and preserve a historical record. My personal commitment to human rights and justice drove me to travel to Afghanistan under Taliban rule.

Can you describe the terms and conditions of the contract you signed with the Taliban?

Journalists must secure Taliban-issued permits, which dictate where they can go and what they can document. There are often bans on filming sensitive topics, particularly women’s issues, and all content may be subject to scrutiny. Complying with these conditions is critical to gaining access, but it also presents ethical dilemmas in ensuring authenticity.

What challenges did you face in obtaining permission to work as a journalist/photo journalist there?

Obtaining permission involved lengthy negotiations, scrutiny of my credentials, and working with local intermediaries who could navigate the Taliban’s bureaucracy. The volatile security situation and pervasive distrust of foreign journalists added to the complexity, but patience and persistence were key.

I had to sign away my freedom to tell their story: A photojournalist on documenting Afghan women under the Taliban

Did your work solely focus on the experience of Afghan women?

Yes, my work primarily focused on women, which provided an intimate window into their lives. This approach highlighted their resilience and underscored their immense risks in speaking out. It demanded sensitivity and discretion in documenting their stories without endangering them.

How were you treated as a Western journalist compared to local women?

Western journalists, particularly women, may be viewed with a mix of suspicion and respect. They often receive more freedom than local women, who live under much stricter conditions. However, both groups face constraints in navigating male-dominated spaces.

What were your first impressions upon arriving and seeing the current state of women’s lives?

The near-total absence of women in public spaces was striking. Their lives seemed confined to the shadows, shaped by fear and resignation. Yet, beneath this, there was a quiet determination, with women finding ways to resist and survive despite the odds.

How do women navigate their daily lives under the strict Taliban-imposed restrictions?

Women have adapted creatively, forming underground networks for education and work. Some rely on male relatives to mediate access to public spaces, while others engage in quiet acts of resistance. The Taliban to some extent has tolerated women to be seen in public with different restrictions. For instance, the Taliban did not allow women to drive but allowed certain women to work in health services.

What were the most striking or surprising moments you witnessed during your time there?

Witnessing the quiet determination of Afghan women to educate their daughters in secret schools, despite severe consequences, was deeply moving. Equally striking was the resilience of families finding joy and hope amidst adversity.

How did you balance respecting local customs with documenting the reality of life for women?

Respecting cultural norms, such as dress codes and social etiquette, was essential to building trust. At the same time, it was important to discreetly capture the raw reality, ensuring stories were told authentically without endangering subjects.

What impact do you hope your work will have in raising awareness about Afghan women’s struggles?

My aim is to shed light on their strength, resilience, and the injustices they face. By keeping their stories alive in the global consciousness, I aim to galvanise international support and influence policies that can bring change.

Keep On Reading

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

Documentary photographer Valentina Sinis tells all about the Iraqi Kurdistan women burning themselves

By Sofia Gallarate

3 ways we can fight for women’s rights all year round (not just on IWD)

By Colette Fountain

Inside the anti-feminist world of Honey Badgers, where women put men’s rights before their own

By Charlie Sawyer

Gen Zers are taking out travel insurance policies for their Labubus ahead of summer

By Charlie Sawyer

SHEIN faces fines from EU for deceiving customers with fake discounts and misleading information

By Eliza Frost

Kim Kardashian wants to know how much a carton of milk costs 

By Eliza Frost

All the Tea on the new app that lets women vet men and date safely

By Eliza Frost

Bad Bunny announced as halftime act for Super Bowl 2026—and conservatives aren’t too happy 

By Eliza Frost

Misogyny, sexism, and the manosphere: how this year’s Love Island UK has taken a step backwards

By Eliza Frost

Netflix is predicting your next favourite show based on your zodiac sign 

By Eliza Frost

Do artists really owe us surprise guests at gigs, or are our expectations out of control?

By Charlie Sawyer

Emma Watson reveals disgusting paparazzi ambush on her 18th birthday

By Charlie Sawyer

UK women who miscarry could face home and phone searches following new anti-abortion police guidance

By Eliza Frost

Online pornography showing choking to be made illegal, says government 

By Eliza Frost

How to spot a performative male out in the wild 

By Eliza Frost

If everyone has an AI boyfriend, what does that mean for the future of Gen Z dating?

By Charlie Sawyer

How rediscovering Nintendogs as an adult has helped my anxiety

By Eliza Frost

Everything to know about Justin Lee Fisher, arrested at Travis Kelce’s home over Taylor Swift deposition papers from Justin Baldoni

By Charlie Sawyer

Call Her Daddy host Alex Cooper accuses former soccer coach of sexual harassment in new docuseries

By Eliza Frost

Taylor Swift is engaged to the boy on the football team, Travis Kelce