AI-generated fake faces are more trustworthy than real people, new study reveals

By Francesca Johnson

Updated May 31, 2023 at 01:53 PM

Reading time: 3 minutes

27511

Can you tell the difference between a human and a machine? Well, recent research has shown that AI-engineered fake faces are more trustworthy to us than real people.

Pulling the wool over our eyes is no easy feat but, over time, fake images of people have become less and less distinguishable from real ones. Researchers at Lancaster University, UK, and the University of California, Berkeley, looked into whether or not fake faces created by machine frameworks could trick people into believing they were real. Sophie J. Nightingale from Lancaster University and Hany Farid at the University of California conducted the new study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA (PNAS).

In the paper, AI programs called GANS (generative adversarial networks), produced fake images of people by “pitting two neural networks against each other,” The New Scientist explained. One network, called the ‘generator’, produced a series of synthetic faces—ever-evolving like an essay’s rough draft. Another network, known as a ‘discriminator’, was first trained on real images, after which it graded the generated output by comparing them to its bank of real face data.

AI-generated fake faces are more trustworthy than real people, new study reveals

Beginning with a few tiny pixels, the generator, with feedback from the discriminator, started to create increasingly realistic images. In fact, they were so realistic that the discriminator itself could no longer tell which ones were fake.

Providing an accurate measure for how much technology has advanced, Nightingale and Farid tested these images on 315 participants. Recruited through a crowdsourcing website, the audience were asked whether or not they could distinguish between 400 fake photos matched to the 400 pictures of real people. The selection of photographs consisted of 100 people from four different ethnic groups: white, black, East Asian and South Asian. As for the result? The test group had a slightly worse-than-chance accuracy rate: around 48.2 per cent.

A second group of 219 participants was also tested. However, this group received training in order to recognise the computer-generated faces. Here, the participants scored a higher accuracy rating of 59 per cent, but according to New Scientist, this difference was “negligible” and nullified in the eyes of Nightingale.

The study found that it was harder for participants to differentiate real from computer-generated faces when the people featured were white. One reason posed for this is due to the synthesis software being trained disproportionately on creating white faces more than any other ethnic groups.

AI-generated fake faces are more trustworthy than real people, new study reveals

The most interesting part of this study comes from tests conducted on a separate group of 223 participants who were asked to rate the trustworthiness of a mix of 128 real and fake photographs. On a scale ranging from one (very untrustworthy) to seven (very trustworthy), participants rated the fake faces as eight per cent more trustworthy, on average, than the pictures of real people. A marginal difference, but a difference nonetheless.

Taking a step back to look at the extreme ends of the results, the four faces that were rated the most untrustworthy were all real, whereas three that were top rated on the trustworthiness scale were fake.

The results of these experiments have prompted researchers to call for safeguards to prevent the circulation of deepfakes online. Not sure what a deepfake is? Well, according to The Guardian, the online epidemic is “the 21st century’s answer to Photoshopping.” The outlet then goes on to describe how they use a form of artificial intelligence called deep learning to make images of fake events. Hence the name.

Ditching their “uncanny valley” telltale sign, deepfakes have evolved to become ”increasingly convincing,” as stated in Scientific American. They have been involved with a series of online crimes including fraud, mistaken identity, the spreading of propaganda and cyber defamation, as well as sexual crimes like revenge porn. This is even more troubling with the knowledge that AI-generated images of people can easily be obtained online by scammers who can then use them to create fake social media profiles. Take the Deepfake Detection Challenge of 2020 for example.

AI-generated fake faces are more trustworthy than real people, new study reveals

“Anyone can create synthetic content without specialized knowledge of Photoshop or CGI,” said Nightingale, who went on to share her thoughts on the options we can consider in order to limit risks when it comes to such technology. Attempting countermeasures against deepfakes has become a Whack-A-Mole situation or cyber “arms race.” Some possibilities for developers include adding watermarks on pictures and using the flagging process when fake ones pop up. However, Nightingale acknowledged how these measures barely make the cut. “In my opinion, this is bad enough. It’s just going to get worse if we don’t do something to stop it.”

“We should be concerned because these synthetic faces are incredibly effective for nefarious purposes, for things like revenge porn or fraud, for example,” Nightingale summed up.

Keep On Reading

By Charlie Sawyer

McDonald’s hit with new mass boycott. Here’s who’s behind it and why

By Charlie Sawyer

Yung Filly’s legal troubles mount as the rapper faces two new sexual assault charges in Australia

By Charlie Sawyer

Gavin Casalegno cancelled? The Summer I Turned Pretty fans turn on him amid cast drama

By Charlie Sawyer

Trump grants white South Africans refuge after ending legal protections for Afghans facing deportation

By Charlie Sawyer

Why Sabrina Carpenter’s sexuality is praised and Lola Young’s is picked apart

By Eliza Frost

How to spot a performative male out in the wild 

By Charlie Sawyer

Lawmakers pressure Trump to provide evidence that Venezuelan asylum seeker Andry Hernández Romero is still alive

By Eliza Frost

Cruz Beckham’s girlfriend Jackie Apostel defends the couple’s age gap relationship 

By Eliza Frost

Louis Tomlinson opens up about Liam Payne’s death and reflects on One Direction’s 15th anniversary

By Charlie Sawyer

Chris Brown is facing over 10 years in prison. Here’s how his violent past has led him here

By Eliza Frost

Taylor Swift is engaged to the boy on the football team, Travis Kelce 

By Eliza Frost

Are you in Group 7? Explaining the latest viral TikTok trend

By Eliza Frost

We finally know why Conrad and Belly broke up in The Summer I Turned Pretty season 2

By Charlie Sawyer

Mexican beauty influencer Valeria Marquez killed during TikTok livestream in alleged femicide

By Charlie Sawyer

Fans express concern after Harry Potter TV series announces the casting of Harry, Ron, and Hermione

By Charlie Sawyer

Emma Watson reveals disgusting paparazzi ambush on her 18th birthday

By Eliza Frost

Bereavement leave to be extended to miscarriages before 24 weeks

By Eliza Frost

Hailey Bieber’s new hands-free lip tint holder has everyone divided 

By Eliza Frost

Why is everyone saying ‘Six-Seven’? The meaning behind the viral phrase

By Charlie Sawyer

SHEIN faces fines from EU for deceiving customers with fake discounts and misleading information