Should you trust your gut, even if you thought it was lying to you?

By Harriet Piercy

Published Feb 14, 2021 at 10:00 AM

Reading time: 4 minutes

14637

Have you ever just known something, without reason or advice? This feeling is sometimes called an ‘inner compass’, ‘sixth sense’, ‘gut feeling’, and other times: it’s probably paranoia. Whichever way you look at it, sceptically or not—every single one of us reading this will have experienced a moment when we were faced with options (subconscious or conscious), and immediately knew which to choose. Because of intuition’s intangibility, it’s a pretty tough thing to study, and yet, it’s impossible not to. After all, truth is alluring—it’s almost sexy. We lust for it like we do for self validation, and it’s why we’re here today.

Let’s start by saying that gut feelings are not magic, they are not delusions and they probably aren’t your rite of passage being laid out before you. They are, on the other hand, complex memories crossed with instinct and remarkably hidden consequence, or luck. Intuition is, unsurprisingly, a popular topic among philosophers and psychologists, and it generally refers to a brain process that gives people the ability to make decisions without the use of analytical reasoning. But what on Earth has the gut got to do with intuition, and why does it literally feel like your tummy, of all things, is telling you to go ‘left, left, I said quick go left!then?

A study led by Melanie Maya Kaelberer, medical instructor at Duke university, along with a team of other researchers looked at mice to determine how the stomach communicated with the brain. Historically, it has been believed that the stomach communicated with the brain indirectly, typically through something called neuropeptide signaling. Peptides are a class of protein-like molecules, and neuropeptides, made in the brain, consist of short chains of amino acids—some of these function as neurotransmitters, and some as hormones. However, thanks to history being a thing of the past, we  now understand that our stomach and brain communicate much more directly. In a nuanced, and complicated way nonetheless.

The study proves gut signals are transmitted at epithelial neural synapses through the release of serotonin. To speak in English, serotonin is a neurotransmitter, which is a chemical that is released when a signal arrives from somewhere else in the body and acts as a bridge for the signal to move from one neuron to another. In other words, this means that the gut has fat chats with your noggin all day long, and if you aren’t eavesdropping, you wouldn’t know it.

It’s a continuous feedback loop, and it’s actually a tool. Imagine making the biggest decision of your life (so far) and asking yourself, ‘what does my gut tell me?’. If you’re one to meticulously weigh up your options, calculate potential outcomes, obsess over what ifs until you end up only ever making the first move on plan G, instead of plan A, then you’re like me. But even I can see that there is something to be said for not solely making purely rational decisions.

For example: we’ve all come across something or someone that ‘we couldn’t quite put our finger on’, or something didn’t ‘sit’ right, but you trust it anyway—because the stats add up, odds are that trusting this thing or person is the right thing to do, because you’ve thoroughly weighed up the statistics. There’s no hard evidence to distrust this thing or person. It’s a safe bet, on paper. So, you forget about any niggling doubts from the beginning, and so you forge ahead. Then a while goes by, and pfft, a thorn has punctured your rolling ball. The thorn ends up being the niggle from right at the beginning, that you now wished you would’ve listened to.

We have trained ourselves, or should I say rather that western society has, to ignore most of what our intuition tells us—how could we possibly trust something that isn’t hard, scientific, data? According to Doctor Judith Orloff, MD, Assistant Clinical Professor of Psychiatry at UCLA and author of Guide To Intuitive Health and The Empath’s Survival Guide, scientists believe that intuition operates through the entire right side of the brain (which is thought to be the more ‘creative’ side), the brain’s hippocampus (which is associated with learning and where new memories are formed) and down through our gut.

In women, the connective white matter that connects our left and right brain hemispheres together is thicker than men’s, which effectively gives us better ability to access each hemisphere—and to further integrate our emotion and gut feelings with the more logical left hemisphere. Basically, women’s brains are wired for rapid intuitive decision making. Culturally, women have been given more permission to be in touch with their feelings, but thankfully, that is changing. However, that being said, Doctor Orloff says that “Because men have a thinner corpus callosum, they are more compartmentalised in their thinking and less about to move back and forth from intuition to logic.”

Research has for a fact shown that intuition exists, and it’s no accident that we use the terms intuition and gut feeling interchangeably—when the neurotransmitters in your gut are firing up, either with ‘butterflies’ or nausea, we’ve got to learn to pay attention. There is such a thing as gaining unconsciously useful information via our brain and body, the gut is often considered our second brain for this reason. The only way to really tap into this tool is to be mindful of it, to question it and to consider its answers carefully. We obviously can’t make every decision by following our gut, but gut instincts, sixth senses, inner compasses or whatever you want to call it, are particularly trustworthy when it comes to intangible rationalisations.

I’ll leave you with one more note: if you ignored your gut, forgive yourself first and foremost. Then if you can, forgive the thorn that came out of that misled decision—and because you can forgive, doesn’t mean that you have to ever trust them again, but it means that your gut won’t be en guard at every new experience, and misleading you out of fear. As it’s been said, the gut is a second brain, it has a memory like the one in our skulls. Forgiving is just another word for untying the knot in your tummy, enabling it to do its job again without expecting every budding plant to have thorns like the last.

Keep On Reading

By Charlie Sawyer

Former Harry Potter star tells reporters he doesn’t understand JK Rowling’s Twitter transphobia

By Charlie Sawyer

Trump administration announces plan to offer US immigrants $1,000 to self-deport

By Charlie Sawyer

Michael Cera reveals why he turned down a role in the Harry Potter franchise

By Eliza Frost

How The Summer I Turned Pretty licensed so much of Taylor Swift’s discography for its soundtrack 

By Fatou Ferraro Mboup

MrBeast hunts for volunteers to test the viral question: who would win between 100 men and one gorilla?

By Eliza Frost

Bad Bunny announced as halftime act for Super Bowl 2026—and conservatives aren’t too happy 

By Eliza Frost

Netflix’s Adolescence sweeps Emmys, with star Owen Cooper making history as youngest-ever male winner

By Eliza Frost

Misinformation spread by wellness influencers online is leading to falling contraceptive pill use

By Charlie Sawyer

Why has the new sculpture of a Black American woman in Times Square prompted mass outrage?

By Charlie Sawyer

Gen Zers are taking out travel insurance policies for their Labubus ahead of summer

By Charlie Sawyer

From breaking up families to spreading rumours about Joe Biden’s death, here’s what QAnons been up to

By Charlie Sawyer

Fans express concern after Harry Potter TV series announces the casting of Harry, Ron, and Hermione

By Abby Amoakuh

I sat down with two professional matchmakers to solve Gen Z’s dating fatigue

By Charlie Sawyer

Yung Filly’s legal troubles mount as the rapper faces two new sexual assault charges in Australia

By Charlie Sawyer

Penn Badgley praised for opening up about fatherhood and raising sons on Call Her Daddy

By Charlie Sawyer

Transformers director Michael Bay officially confirmed to direct movie about viral Skibidi Toilet meme

By Abby Amoakuh

Campaigners call for gamers who carry out virtual rape in the metaverse to be charged as real-life sex offenders

By Charlie Sawyer

Chris Brown is facing over 10 years in prison. Here’s how his violent past has led him here

By Alma Fabiani

Amazon Music is giving away 4 months free. Here’s how to claim it

By Eliza Frost

Sabrina Carpenter says you need to get out more if you think Man’s Best Friend artwork is controversial